How Far in Advance Should You Buy the Engagement Ring?

• IGI-certified diamonds
• Triple Excellent standard
• Lifetime setting upgrades
• Free, fully insured shipping
• Made to order in Toronto

Most Montare rings are made to order in about three to four weeks — so start at least that far ahead, and add a buffer for sizing and for choosing your moment. A great ring is made to order, not pulled off a shelf, and it is almost always the longest-lead item in a proposal plan. Here is what actually drives that timeline, the order things have to happen in, and the two periods of the year when starting earlier matters most.

Key takeaways

• A made-to-order ring is built around your stone and setting — it is not instant.
• Made to order in roughly 3–4 weeks for most designs; a fully bespoke piece takes longer.
• Ring size is the most common cause of delay — sort it early.
• Nearly half of all proposals happen between late November and mid-February; start well ahead of that window.
• Always leave a buffer for sizing and for choosing your moment.
• If time is short, proposing with a placeholder and designing together afterwards is a genuinely good option.

Why a made-to-order ring takes time

Unlike a mass-produced ring sitting in a case, a made-to-order ring does not exist until it is built for you. Each stage depends on the one before it, which is why the process cannot simply be compressed.

Stage	What happens	What can extend it
1. The brief	You describe the shape, size and look you want	Nothing — this is the quick part
2. Sourcing the stone	We go and find the best diamond that clears the standard	Unusual shapes, very large stones, tight specifications
3. Building the setting	The mount is cast and finished by hand	Bespoke or heavily personalised designs
4. Setting the stone	The diamond is set into the finished mount	Pavé, halos and multi-stone work take longer
5. Quality check and finish	Final polish and inspection before it leaves	Anything that needs correcting is corrected
6. Sizing buffer	Any adjustment after it reaches you	Not knowing the ring size in advance

Notice that stage two is a search, not a transaction. We do not pick from a tray of stock — you tell us what you are looking for and we go and source the stone that meets the floor. That is the part people underestimate, and it is also the part that produces a better ring.

The honest answer on timing

For most designs, a Montare ring is made to order in Toronto in about three to four weeks. That covers sourcing the stone, building the setting, setting it and finishing the piece. A fully bespoke design — starting from a blank page rather than adapting an existing setting — takes longer, and we will tell you how much longer for your specific piece rather than quoting an average.

The practical rule: work back from your date, allow the three to four weeks, then add a buffer for sizing and for choosing your moment. Ask us for the timeline on your specific piece when you enquire, and we will tell you honestly, including if what you want cannot be done by your date. What we will not do is rush the work to hit an arbitrary deadline. Nothing here is built for stock, and no ring is hurried along to clear a shelf or catch a shipping cut-off; the aim is never to get a piece out the door as fast as possible, it is to make the best piece possible. Starting early is what lets both things be true at once.

Get these in the right order

Whatever your timeline, the sequence matters more than the calendar.

• First, the shape and the budget. These two together determine everything downstream. Explore in the ring builder or book a consultation.
• Then the setting. See engagement ring settings explained — this is also when to decide on metal.
• Then confirm the stone. Once the specification is fixed, the search can begin.
• Ring size, as early as possible. Do not leave this to the end. See how to find her ring size without asking.
• Last, the moment. Plan the proposal around a ring you already have, not one you are waiting for — see proposal ideas in Toronto.

The most common cause of delay is ring size

It is worth singling out, because it catches people who did everything else right. A ring finished to the wrong size has to go back for adjustment, and that adjustment sits at the very end of the process — precisely where there is no slack left.

Two things help. Establish the size while the ring is still being designed rather than after it is made. And know that guessing slightly large is the safer error, since a ring is generally easier to size down than up. One exception: a full eternity band cannot easily be resized at all, because stones run the whole way around and leave no plain shank to cut. If that is the design, the size has to be right first time.

The two times of year to start earliest

Proposals are not evenly spread across the calendar, and this affects everyone in the industry at once. According to The Knot's research, roughly 47% of couples get engaged between Thanksgiving and Valentine's Day, with December the single most popular month worldwide and Christmas Day the most popular day of all. Valentine's Day is the other spike.

The practical consequence is straightforward: if you are proposing at Christmas, New Year or Valentine's, you are planning inside the busiest window of the year for every jeweller, diamond supplier and setter simultaneously. Summer is the second cluster, driven by holidays and warm-weather proposals. None of this changes how long your ring takes to make, but it does mean that leaving it late in those windows leaves you with fewer options and no room for anything to go wrong. If your date falls in engagement season, bring everything forward.

Build in a buffer

Always leave a little slack. Sizing adjustments, a change of heart on a detail, or simply wanting to wait for the right moment all go more smoothly with breathing room. Starting early costs nothing and removes essentially all of the stress — and a calmer decision is usually a better one. Most of the regret we hear about is not "I spent too much" but "I rushed it".

What if you are short on time?

It can still be done, and a consultation is the fastest way to get a realistic plan — we would rather tell you honestly what is possible than take an order we cannot do justice to.

There is also a genuinely good alternative that removes the deadline entirely: propose with a placeholder and design the real ring together afterwards. More couples do this than you would think, and it has real advantages — the proposal happens when you want it to, she gets a say in the ring she will wear for the rest of her life, and nobody is rushed. If the surprise matters more than the object, this is often the better plan rather than the fallback.

Plan it with Montare

We are a Toronto-based, made-to-order house, shipping free and fully insured across Canada. Tell us your timeline and we will tell you plainly what is achievable — to the full standard: lab-grown, D–E colour, VVS1–VVS2 clarity, Triple Excellent cut with table and depth in the ideal range for the shape, three carats minimum, IGI certified. The per-shape figures are on our standards. Our goldsmiths cast, set and polish every ring by hand here in the city. Start in the ring builder or book a consultation.

Frequently asked questions

How far in advance should I buy an engagement ring?

Most Montare rings are made to order in about three to four weeks, so start at least that far ahead and add a buffer for sizing and for choosing your moment. A fully bespoke design takes longer. The ring is the longest-lead item in any proposal plan, so it is the thing to begin first.

Why does an engagement ring take time to make?

Because it does not exist until it is built for you. We source a diamond that meets the standard, the setting is cast and finished by hand, the stone is set, and the ring is checked and polished — each stage depending on the one before it.

Can I get an engagement ring quickly?

Sometimes, depending on the design. A consultation is the fastest route to a realistic answer, and we would rather tell you honestly what is possible than rush the work. If time is genuinely short, proposing with a placeholder and designing the real ring together afterwards is a good option.

What should I sort out before ordering?

Your budget, the shape and the setting — and ideally her ring size, which is the single most common cause of delay because any adjustment happens at the very end of the process.

When is the busiest time of year to buy an engagement ring?

The winter holidays. Around 47% of couples get engaged between Thanksgiving and Valentine's Day, with December the most popular month and Christmas Day the most popular single day. Summer is a second, smaller cluster. If your date falls in either window, start earlier than you otherwise would.

Is it better to propose with a placeholder ring?

For some couples, yes. It removes the deadline, lets the proposal happen when you want it to, and means she helps choose the ring she will wear for life. If the surprise matters more than the object itself, it is often the better plan rather than a compromise.

What happens if the ring is the wrong size?

It is adjusted. Every Montare ring includes a free resizing within the first 60 days, and we support resizing beyond that for the life of the ring. Guessing slightly large is the safer error, since rings are easier to size down than up — though full eternity bands cannot easily be resized at all.

Should I choose the ring before planning the proposal?

Yes. Plan the moment around a ring you already have rather than one you are still waiting for. The ring is the longest-lead item in the plan, so it should be started first and confirmed before you fix a date and a location.

Start early, propose calmly. Begin in the ring builder or book a consultation.